Court finds UK allowed undervalued Chinese imports into EU
March 12, 2022, 1:40:01 CET | Wikinews

Friday, March 11, 2022 

Economy and business

Related articles

11 March 2022: Court finds UK allowed undervalued Chinese imports into EU
9 March 2022: United States bans importation of Russian fossil fuels
8 March 2022: Financial Action Task Force places United Arab Emirates on money laundering 'grey' list
28 February 2022: Russia continues to attack Ukraine amid sanctions from the west
5 February 2022: Russia and China sign major gas pipeline deal for 30 years


Pillars of Wikinews writing
Writing an article

European Court of Justice Towers B and C in Luxembourg on July 3, 2021. Image: Luxofluxo.
The European Anti-Fraud Office in Brussels, Belgium on May 11, 2011. Image: Matthias v.d. Elbe.
Weaver in Pingtang County, China on November 14, 2019. Image: Lkjidm.
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled on Tuesday the United Kingdom neglected its obligations as a former European Union member for allowing "undervalued imports of textiles and footwear from China" to enter EU markets.

The European Commission argued HM Revenue and Customs "failed to fulfil its obligations" under EU law by collecting insufficient customs duty and value-added tax payments for Chinese clothes and shoes imports from 2011-17. In 2017, over half of such products were found by the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) to be imported below "the lowest acceptable prices".

Lowest acceptable prices are a risk assessment tool introduced by OLAF to detect "imports presenting a significant risk of undervaluation". OLAF informed member states of the chance for "extreme undervaluation" by shell companies, including during bilateral meetings with the UK over 2015 and 2016. Despite this, the ECJ found British authorities did not utilise the metric for its monitoring operations in 2011 and 2014.

As a result, it did not conduct "appropriate customs controls", allowing the products "free circulation in the internal market". As an example, fraud investigators in 2017 found women's trousers from China were declared at €0.91 per kilogram, €0.53 below the market price for cotton. The Commission estimates this cost the EU budget €2.68 billion (~$2.9 billion) from 2011-17, as 80% of customs duties go toward funding the EU's budget.

However, the ECJ denied the Commission's request the UK provide such a sum as repayment, citing inconsistencies with its full amount calculations which meant it had not met the "requisite legal standard". The UK remains under ECJ jurisdiction for infractions made during its EU membership even after leaving the EU in January 2020. The UK was ordered to pay four-fifths of legal costs Brussels incurred since OLAF first alleged misconduct in 2017.

The UK can challenge the fine, but not the result from the judgment. The fine amount €2.68 billion is up from the original €1.99 billion in lost duties uncovered from a sophisticated fraud ring. However, while today's sum was taken from 2011-17, the investigation initially focused on evidence from 2013-16 in the ports of Felixstowe and Dover, England.

At the time, a representative for then-Prime Minister Theresa May said the sum was "not a bill. It's an estimate" and "we don't recognise the figures."

The Luxembourg-based court concluded the British government failed "to apply effective customs control measures or to enter in the accounts the correct amounts of customs duties". It added the "inadequate nature of the checks carried out by the United Kingdom customs authorities" allowed fraudulent shell companies to move their operations to the UK.

The ECJ concluded the UK had also failed "to provide the Commission with all the information necessary" to make its own calculations.

The UK remained opposed to the EU's methods against calculating undervalued goods, and was supported in doing so by Belgium, Estonia, Greece, Latvia, Portugal and Slovakia. Of them, Portugal, Slovakia and the UK, as well as Malta and Spain, were found to have "major undervaluation hubs" in the first month of OLAF's 2014 Operation Snake.

British ports, specifically Dover, were found to be the main entry points for Chinese goods before clearing European customs and being trafficked across the continent. Bruno Collin, head of a French anti-fraud operation in 2016, lamented to Politico Europe the unhelpfulness of British authorities. He said only "extremely vague answers" were given to French requests, if they responded at all.

When OLAF first reported on the UK's "continuous negligence" to combat fraud, HM Revenue told Politico Europe it boasted an "excellent record in tackling fraud and rule breaking of all kinds". Collin, however, concluded: "They don't make an effort."

Have an opinion on this story? Share it!

Press Release: "Judgment in Case C-213/19" — Court of Justice of the European Union, March 8, 2022 (PDF)
Andrew Woodcock. "UK 'failed' by letting cheap Chinese clothes flood EU market" — The Independent, March 8, 2022
Jennifer Rankin, Daniel Boffey. "UK faces large EU bill over Chinese imports fraud" — The Guardian, March 8, 2022
"EU court rules against UK over multibillion-euro customs fraud" — Reuters, March 8, 2022
Giulia Paravicini. "UK faces €2 billion EU tab for China fraud" — Politico Europe, March 8, 2017
Jennifer Rankin. "UK faces €2bn fine over Chinese imports scam, say EU investigators" — The Guardian, March 8, 2017

Share this: 

Source: Wikinews
Share this article:
share article on facebook share article on twitter share article on google+ share article on tumblr share article on blogger share article on reddit

Articles that may interest you:

European Commission, five EU members agree to...

Thursday, May 4, 2023  2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine Related articles 4 May 2023: E...

Ethics chief: UK PM's reforms after Partygate...

Friday, June 3, 2022  Politics and conflicts Related articles 17 May 2022: UAE Preside...

UK defers junk food deals, advertisement rest...

Tuesday, May 17, 2022  Health Related articles 17 May 2022: Bans off Our Bodies protes...
Send us your articles and web-novels!
comments powered by Disqus
Most popular

Recently Viewed:

Court finds UK allowed undervalued Chinese imports i...

Friday, March 11, 2022  Economy and business Related articles 11 March 2022: Court fin...

Cody Walker has joined ROWW as brand manager

Cody Walker, younger brother of Paul Walker has decided to join Reach Out Worldwide; a found...

Scottish Labour elect Kezia Dugdale new leader

Kezia Dugdale MSP (Member of Scottish Parliament) has been elected as the new leader for Sco...

BBC apologises after 'Manchester United are rubbish'...

Sunday, May 29, 2022  BBC Related articles 29 May 2022: BBC apologises after 'Manchest...

Russian authorities charge US reporter Evan Gershkov...

Wednesday, April 12, 2023  Lefortovo Prison in 2016. Image: A.Savin. Crime and law Relate...

Reviews | Technology | Projects & Tuning | Events | Racing
Business & Technology
Business & Economy | Mobile | Internet & Media | Security & Privacy | Gadgets & Tech | Software
Health, Food & Fitness | Fashion | Gardening | DIY | Homes
Accidents | Crime | Culture | Finance | Politics
Science & Environment
Wildlife | Green | Space
Accidents | Crime | Culture | Finance | Politics
Copyright & Privacy | Site Roadmap | Sitemap | Contact
Web Development @ OverHertz Ltd